My Friend Reserved a Baby Name for Her Imaginary Son and Told Me I Couldn’t Use It!

Choosing a baby name is one of the most exciting parts of becoming a parent. But for one 35-year-old woman, this happy time became stressful because of a disagreement with a friend. After trying to have a baby for almost two years, she finally became pregnant with her first child through fertility treatment. At six months pregnant, she was looking forward to her baby shower, where friends and family would find out if she was having a boy or a girl. Everyone was excited to celebrate this special moment with her.

The problem started when her friend, whom we will call Pooja, learned that she was expecting a boy. Pooja already had two daughters and had never shown much interest in having another child. However, she suddenly said that she and her husband might try for a third baby because they wanted a son. Then she made a surprising request. She told the pregnant woman that she must never use a certain baby name because Pooja had already saved it for her future son. She even said that the other woman could use the name only if she never had a boy. This was not the first time something like this had happened. About a year earlier, Pooja had also become upset when the woman mentioned another boy’s name. The couple later decided to choose a different name to avoid further problems.

The expectant mother finally decided to speak up. She explained that every parent has the right to choose a name for their own child and that nobody can claim ownership of a baby name. Pooja did not take the conversation well and accused her of being rude and making a big deal out of nothing. Now, some of their mutual friends are taking different sides. The pregnant woman is left wondering if she was wrong to defend her choice. For her, choosing a baby name should be a personal decision between parents, not something controlled by a friend.

DELL-E

Baby Names, Personal Boundaries, and the Problem With Competition

Choosing a baby name is one of the most exciting parts of becoming a parent. Many couples spend months looking at baby name ideas, checking meanings, and discussing which names they like.

For some parents, a name also has a special family meaning. It may remind them of someone they love or represent something important in their lives.

That is why arguments about baby names can sometimes become emotional.

But this story is not really about two children having the same name. It is about one person trying to control another couple’s decision based on a name she might want to use in the future.

The question is simple: Can someone really claim a baby name before they even have another child?

Can Someone Reserve a Baby Name for the Future?

The short answer is no.

In everyday life, people cannot simply claim ownership of a first name because they hope to use it for a future baby.

For example, Pooja can tell her friends that she loves a particular name and wants to give it to her future son.

She can even discuss that name with her husband and make plans around it.

However, she cannot expect another couple to avoid that name just because she likes it.

In the United States, trademark law protects certain names and words when they are used for business purposes. The Lanham Act, 15 U.S.C. § 1052, explains some of the rules for trademark registration.

However, this is very different from claiming a personal baby name for a child who may be born in the future.

A name used for a business or commercial brand is not the same as a name chosen by parents for their baby.

In simple words, Pooja can have a favorite baby name, but she cannot make the decision for another family.

Parents should be free to choose a name they love without feeling that they need permission from their friends.

Why Parents Can Become So Attached to Baby Names

Choosing a baby name can mean much more than finding something that sounds beautiful.

A 2025 study published in Names: A Journal of Onomastics, titled What’s in Our Name? Exploring Meaning and Narrative Identity in Parents’ Naming of Firstborn, looked at how parents feel about choosing names for their children.

Researchers Aelia Ackerman and Hadas Wiseman interviewed 12 first-time parents.

They found that baby names were connected to personal identity, family relationships, individuality, and parents’ hopes for their children.

This shows why some parents become deeply attached to a particular name.

They may have imagined their future child with that name for years. They may have discussed it with their partner or connected it with an important family memory.

Another 2009 study by Todd Gureckis and Robert Goldstone, published in Topics in Cognitive Science, explored how social trends influence baby naming choices.

The research showed that parents can be influenced by how popular a name is and whether its popularity is increasing.

This means baby name choices are influenced by both personal feelings and what people see around them.

However, loving a name does not give someone control over another person’s decision.

Pooja may have always imagined having a son with that particular name. There is nothing wrong with that.

The problem begins when she expects her friend to avoid the name simply because she wants to use it someday.

There is a big difference between sharing a personal preference and telling someone else what they are allowed to do.

Is Pooja Jealous or Simply Too Attached to the Name?

This is probably the most interesting part of the story.

The timing of Pooja’s announcement made the situation more uncomfortable for her pregnant friend.

Pooja had previously said that she was happy with her two daughters and did not want another baby.

But shortly after learning that her friend was expecting a boy, she suddenly announced that she wanted to try for a third child.

It is understandable why the pregnant woman found this surprising.

She may have wondered whether Pooja was genuinely changing her family plans or feeling competitive about the situation.

However, it is important not to assume someone’s intentions without knowing the full story.

There could be several reasons behind Pooja’s decision.

1. She may have changed her mind about having another baby.

People sometimes change their minds about family planning. Pooja may genuinely want another child now, even if she felt differently before.

2. She may be feeling competitive.

Seeing a friend reach an exciting milestone can sometimes bring up unexpected feelings. However, this does not prove that jealousy is the reason behind her actions.

3. She may feel very attached to certain names.

Some people become so connected to their favorite baby names that they struggle when someone else wants to use the same one.

4. She may have trouble respecting other people’s choices.

Repeatedly telling another couple which names they can or cannot use suggests a problem with personal boundaries.

We cannot know which explanation is correct based on one person’s account.

But one thing is clear: Pooja’s repeated comments have made her friend uncomfortable during an important time in her life.

Why Personal Boundaries Matter During Pregnancy

Pregnancy can be an emotional and sometimes stressful experience.

This can be especially true for couples who have spent a long time trying to conceive.

In this story, the expectant mother had been trying to get pregnant for almost two years and had also gone through fertility treatment.

After such a long pregnancy journey, it is understandable that she wants to enjoy this special time with her husband.

She should not have to deal with unnecessary arguments about what she can name her baby.

Choosing a baby’s name is a personal parenting decision. Friends and relatives can share suggestions when asked, but the final choice belongs to the parents.

A healthy friendship should allow people to respect each other’s decisions, even when they do not agree.

The woman can set a simple boundary without turning the situation into a bigger argument.

For example, she could say:

“I understand that you really love this name and hope you get to use it someday. But my husband and I will choose our baby’s name ourselves. I would rather not argue about it.”

This response is polite but clear.

There is also no need to involve other friends or continue discussing the same issue again and again.

The couple can simply choose the name they love and enjoy preparing for their baby’s arrival.

3. Final Verdict: Is She the AITA?

Verdict: NTA.

The expectant mother is not wrong for standing up for her right to choose her baby’s name.

Pooja is allowed to have favorite names, make plans for future children, and hope to use a particular name someday.

But having a favorite name and telling someone else they cannot use it are two very different things.

The biggest concern is not that Pooja suddenly wants another baby. People are allowed to change their minds about family planning.

The bigger issue is that she has repeatedly tried to tell another couple which name they should avoid, even when her friend was not pregnant at the time.

That said, calling Pooja immature may have made the disagreement more personal. A calm conversation could have helped avoid some of the friendship problems.

Still, the woman’s main point is completely reasonable.

After everything she and her husband went through to become parents, they deserve to enjoy choosing their baby’s name without asking a friend for permission.

At the end of the day, baby names are a personal choice. Friends can share their opinions, but they cannot make naming decisions for someone else’s child.

The bottom line: Baby names are not private reservations. Loving a name does not mean you own it, and nobody can stop another family from choosing the same one.

Readers’ Comments Speak Out