"AITA For backing out on an agreement my husband and I made years ago regarding potential kid names?"

In this scenario, the couple, married for 11 years with two daughters and expecting a third child, faces a significant disagreement over naming their unborn son. The husband, who is a “third” in his family lineage, had made it clear before marriage that passing down his name was important to him if they had a son. However, the wife, who initially found his sentimentality endearing, has since cooled on the idea and no longer feels comfortable with naming their son after her husband in the same way.

The conflict arises when the couple discovers through an ultrasound that they are expecting a boy, reigniting the husband’s excitement about passing down his name. However, the wife expresses her change of heart, citing concerns about the tackiness and aristocratic connotations of having a “fourth” in the family. She proposes considering other names but is met with disappointment and withdrawal from her husband, who feels betrayed by her reversal on their years-long agreement.

The husband’s sudden change in mood and withdrawal of excitement about the baby indicate the depth of his disappointment and hurt over his wife’s decision. Despite her attempts to discuss and compromise by suggesting alternative names, he remains firm in his stance, feeling that her change of heart constitutes a breach of trust.

The wife acknowledges her prior agreement but struggles with the idea of naming their son after her husband in the same manner, seeking time to consider other options. Despite her intentions to find a solution together, the husband’s emotional reaction complicates the situation, leaving the couple at an impasse and affecting their communication and connection during what should be a joyful time.

Read for more info Reddit