"AITA for offering two different kinds of cake at our wedding?"

In the scenario presented, a couple named Josh and their spouse, whose name wasn’t mentioned, recently held their wedding where they decided to offer two different types of cake to their guests. Initially planning a smaller wedding, they received additional funds allowing them to expand their guest list to include extended family and friends. Due to budget constraints, they opted for a “fancy” cake for immediate family and close members, providing them with boxed slices to take home. For the rest of the guests, they served sheet cakes: one vanilla with buttercream and another pineapple chocolate chunk, intended as a nod to Josh’s family who spends time in Florida.

Following the wedding, they learned through family members that the pineapple chocolate chunk cake did not resonate well with Josh’s side of the family. Many guests left full slices uneaten, which was evident in wedding photos. This revelation came as a surprise to Josh and their spouse, who were unaware of the negative feedback until after the event. Compounding the issue, they discovered that some guests had been gossiping about the cake, leading to hurtful comments shared behind their backs.

The couple, feeling hurt by the criticism, particularly from Josh’s uncle whose text message accidentally revealed his displeasure, are unsure how to address the situation. They believe they were generous with their offerings considering their budget, which included a full dinner, cheese selections, and an open bar. Despite their efforts to cater to different tastes and preferences, they now face the aftermath of guests’ disappointment over the cake choices.

In conclusion, while Josh and their spouse attempted to accommodate a diverse group of guests with their cake choices, they inadvertently received negative feedback that has left them feeling hurt and unsure of how to respond. The situation has highlighted differing expectations and tastes among guests, sparking post-wedding tensions that they hadn’t anticipated.

Read for more info Reddit