"AITA for calling my brother a hypocrite for refusing to come to my wedding because it's child-free?"

In this family wedding dilemma, tensions have arisen between the engaged person (F27) and her brother Josh (M32) over the decision to have a child-free wedding. The engaged couple has chosen not to invite children under 13 to their wedding, citing reasons like potential boredom for young guests. Josh, who has twins aged 5, has adamantly refused to attend the wedding, labeling the decision as selfish and exclusionary towards his children.

The situation is complicated by the fact that Josh and his wife had a child-free wedding themselves seven years ago, which adds a layer of perceived hypocrisy to his objections. Despite attempts by the engaged person to reason with Josh and reaffirm his invitation to attend without his children, tensions escalated when Josh made disparaging remarks at a family gathering, prompting a heated exchange where he was called a hypocrite by the engaged person.

Family dynamics have further deteriorated, with parents becoming involved. The engaged person’s father has stated he won’t attend the wedding if Josh isn’t there, while her mother has urged her to reconsider and make an exception for Josh’s children, framing the engaged person’s stance as narcissistic and resistant to compromise.

The engaged person feels justified in their decision, believing Josh should respect their wishes as they respected his in the past. However, the situation has polarized the family, with strong opinions and ultimatums being issued from both sides.

In evaluating whether the engaged person is the asshole (AITA), perspectives could differ based on individual beliefs regarding wedding etiquette, family obligations, and the importance of accommodating children at family events. The engaged person’s firm stance on their wedding’s child-free policy reflects their personal preferences and logistical considerations, but the fallout with Josh and family members suggests potential for reconciliation efforts or compromises to ease tensions. The engaged person’s response to Josh’s criticism, while emotional, may have escalated the conflict rather than resolving it diplomatically.

Ultimately, while the engaged person’s decision is within their rights, navigating familial expectations and relationships may require delicate handling to mitigate further discord and ensure everyone feels respected and included.

Read for more info Reddit