'AITA for kicking out my MIL for forcing my child to eat something?'

In this scenario, a mother finds herself embroiled in a conflict involving her mother-in-law (MIL) and her daughter’s strong dislike for mushrooms. The daughter, aged 10, has a genuine aversion to mushrooms, which her MIL consistently disregards when preparing meals, often making dishes that prominently feature mushrooms despite knowing the girl’s distaste. This results in the daughter feeling forced to either eat something she dislikes or go hungry for the night, as her MIL refuses to provide an alternative.

The situation reaches a breaking point when both parents, who work in demanding medical professions, confront the MIL about her actions. Instead of acknowledging the problem, the MIL insists that the girl needs to overcome her aversion and accuses the parents of neglecting their child by not handling her food preferences more strictly. This leads to a heated exchange where the mother ultimately asks her MIL to leave their home.

Supported by her husband, who agrees that his mother’s behavior is unacceptable, the mother stands firm in her decision to prioritize her daughter’s well-being and emotional comfort over accommodating her MIL’s actions. Despite this, the MIL and other family members, including sisters-in-law, criticize the mother and father for evicting the MIL, arguing that the daughter needs to adapt and accept the meals provided.

In evaluating the situation, many would agree that the mother is not in the wrong (Not the A-hole). She and her husband have shown concern for their daughter’s feelings and dietary preferences, rightfully expecting their MIL to respect those preferences rather than impose her own beliefs on the child. By asking the MIL to leave after a clear refusal to acknowledge or respect their parenting decisions, the parents asserted their responsibility to protect their child from emotional distress and unnecessary conflict at meal times. The disagreement with extended family underscores the differing perspectives on parenting and food preferences, but ultimately reinforces the parents’ commitment to their daughter’s well-being.

Read for more info Reddit