AITA for not letting my brother's gf sit with us at my wedding?

In this scenario, the bride was faced with a dilemma at her wedding regarding seating arrangements for photographs. She had meticulously planned her special day for almost two years, aiming for perfection in every detail. Her brother’s girlfriend, who had not warmed up to her and appeared distant, was invited as a guest. The bride specifically wanted only the wedding party seated with her and her husband for staged candid photos immediately after the ceremony, to ensure color coordination and an even number of people in the shots.

When the bride’s brother attempted to pull up a chair for his girlfriend to join them, she politely but firmly asked him not to, explaining the need to maintain the planned seating for the photos. This led to the girlfriend feeling offended and ultimately choosing to sit at a back table, which upset the brother. Tensions escalated when the bride expressed frustration, feeling that her wishes for the day were being disregarded, especially as she wanted her wedding photos to reflect joy and harmony.

The bride’s insistence on the seating arrangement was driven by her long-held vision for the wedding, compounded by her perception that the girlfriend’s demeanor might not have been conducive to the celebratory atmosphere she wanted to capture. However, her brother reacted strongly to what he perceived as his girlfriend being excluded and unwelcome, leading to a heated exchange and subsequent silence between them.

In hindsight, while the bride feels justified in wanting her day to go as planned, her delivery and handling of the situation may have inadvertently caused hurt feelings. The fallout has left family and friends feeling awkward and unwilling to take sides. The bride’s attempts to apologize and offer reconciliation have been met with continued tension. Ultimately, while the bride’s intentions were to ensure a perfect day, the fallout has underscored the importance of balancing personal expectations with sensitivity towards others’ feelings, especially in familial relationships during such significant events.

Read for more info Reddit