AITA for calling my sister sick and disgusting for taking a eulogy I wrote for our grandpa as her own

In a recent family dispute, a 22-year-old man found himself embroiled in conflict with his older sister over a eulogy he wrote for their late grandfather. The young man, who was initially hesitant about speaking at the funeral but was eventually persuaded by his grandmother, poured significant effort into crafting a heartfelt and personal speech. He shared the eulogy via Google Docs with his family, including his sister.

Despite his preparation, his mother and grandmother decided that his sister would deliver the speech instead, which he accepted with some reluctance. However, his sister’s delivery of the eulogy was problematic: she used his exact words and personal anecdotes as if they were her own experiences. This appropriation of his work led to a strong emotional reaction from him, especially when family members praised his sister for the “beautiful” speech.

Image credits: Andrea Piacquadio (not the actual photo)

Feeling deeply betrayed, he confronted his sister, calling her actions “sick and disgusting.” His mother responded by dismissing his feelings, suggesting he was being selfish and that his sister’s lack of time justified her actions. The young man is now questioning whether he was wrong to express his frustration, given the emotional and complex nature of the situation.

This situation highlights a delicate balance between family dynamics and personal boundaries, especially during times of grief. The young man’s response underscores the emotional impact of having one’s work appropriated, while the family’s reaction reflects differing views on appropriateness and the handling of such personal matters.

Read for more info Reddit