AITA for getting my fiance's family gifts that were too personal for Christmas when I'm new to them?

In this situation, a woman recently engaged to Noah spent her first Christmas with his family, aiming to express her appreciation through thoughtful gifts. Despite her efforts to personalize each gift based on what she knew of their interests and preferences, such as making a book sleeve for a sister who loves reading or getting a jewelry box for his mom, the family reacted negatively. They considered the gifts too personal and accused her of overstepping boundaries, with one sister even labeling her actions as creepy and implying her troubled upbringing was to blame for her behavior.

Feeling deeply hurt by the family’s response, she apologized profusely and offered to make amends, but received no reassurance or acceptance from them. Her fiancé, Noah, supported her, insisting she did nothing wrong and that his family owed her an apology instead. Despite this, the family’s reaction left her feeling guilty and questioning her intentions.

The woman clarified that she had met Noah’s family before Christmas but was still relatively new to them. She acknowledged her difficult past and expressed her vulnerability, seeking validation and understanding. Ultimately, she decided to focus on building her confidence and seeking guidance from therapy to navigate the complexities of family dynamics.

In summary, while the woman’s intentions were to show gratitude and create meaningful connections with her fiancé’s family, her efforts were misinterpreted and rejected. The incident highlighted misunderstandings and differences in expectations within the family, leaving her emotionally affected and seeking support to move forward positively.

Read for more info Reddit