"AITA for not wanting my MIL to be in the hospital room when I give birth to my daughter?"

Image credits: Jonathan Borba (not the actual photo)

In a recent online discussion about birth plans, a 22-year-old expectant mother faced a challenging situation with her 28-year-old husband regarding who should be present during their daughter’s birth.

The couple had initially discussed their preferences, but the husband’s sudden insistence on having his mother in the delivery room led to a heated argument. The expectant mother clarified her preference for a more private birthing experience, expressing discomfort with the idea of his mother being present during the delivery, especially given previous negative interactions.

Respondents in the discussion largely supported the expectant mother’s stance, emphasizing that childbirth is an intensely personal and vulnerable experience. Many highlighted that, while the baby’s arrival is a shared event, the person giving birth has the ultimate say in who is present during the delivery. The consensus was that the birthing process should be respected as a medical procedure rather than a public spectacle.

Commenters suggested that the mother-to-be should clearly communicate her wishes to the medical staff, who would then ensure that her preferences are respected. They also pointed out that the focus should remain on the comfort and support of the birthing person rather than accommodating additional spectators. The general advice was to prioritize the expectant mother’s needs and ensure that her experience remains as positive and supportive as possible.