"AITA for not wanting wife on deed to new house?"

In this scenario, the husband is grappling with the decision of whether to include his wife on the deed to their new house. The couple has been married for three years with separate finances, and the wife has been primarily caring for their child at home since leaving her job. They both own separate homes from before their marriage, and the husband has been supporting a joint account for his wife’s expenses.

The couple found a new home they want to purchase together, but financial arrangements have become a point of contention. The wife is reluctant to sell her home or contribute her substantial savings to the new house, citing her role as a stay-at-home mother as her significant contribution. She feels her work as a mom should be recognized, even though the husband contends he has never discouraged her from returning to work and has offered childcare arrangements.

The husband, who earns significantly more, has proposed that while he doesn’t expect the wife to pay half of the down payment or contribute to monthly payments, he insists she should contribute a reasonable amount from her savings if she wants to be on the deed. He argues that if he’s to sell his premarital home and cover most financial aspects of the new home, the deed should reflect his greater financial investment.

The wife perceives this stance as devaluing her role and contributions as a mother. She equates fairness with physical contributions, humorously suggesting that if fairness were truly the goal, he should carry and deliver their next child (which is biologically impossible).

In conclusion, while the husband’s perspective emphasizes financial equity and the tangible contributions to the new home, the wife feels her non-financial contributions and role as a mother should be equally valued in their joint decision-making. The conflict underscores deeper issues of how each partner defines contribution and fairness within their marriage.

Read for more info Reddit