"AITA for refusing to change my baby's name?"

In a recent family situation, a woman (F32) and her partner (M34) welcomed their newborn son, Liam Alexander. The couple chose the name Liam after much deliberation, and they were thrilled with their decision.

However, complications arose when the partner’s sister, Katie, visited to meet the baby. Katie expressed her disappointment that she could not use the name Liam for her own children due to her husband’s past relationship. Mike has a daughter with his ex, who shares the name Liam with Katie’s first son.

Katie’s reaction was unexpected when she requested the new parents to reconsider their choice, suggesting they rename their son Alexander instead. She argued that since Mike’s ex also has a son named Liam, it was uncomfortable for her. Despite her request, the new mother firmly refused to alter the baby’s name or its order, emphasizing her deep affection for the name Liam. This led to a repeat of the request from Katie during a subsequent visit, which further strained the situation.

Image credits: Kristina Paukshtite (not the actual photo)

The new mother explained that Liam is a common name in her culture and that she felt no need to accommodate Katie’s preferences, given that the boys with the same name lived separate lives and had no direct connection. She acknowledged the potential impact of Katie’s complicated relationship with Mike and his ex but stood by her decision. Despite feeling some guilt, she maintained that she had no obligation to change the name for Katie’s comfort.

In this situation, the new mother is not at fault for sticking to her chosen name for her son. The request to change the name, based on a past partner’s child, seems unreasonable and intrusive. The new parents had no prior agreement with Katie regarding baby names, and cultural significance and personal preference should be prioritized in such matters.

Read for more info Reddit