'AITA for saying what I really think in family therapy?'

Based on the situation described, the 15-year-old girl (OP) attended family therapy with her dad, stepmom (who she considers as her mom), and stepsister (16-year-old). The therapy sessions were initiated to address longstanding issues stemming from her stepsister’s rejection and hostility towards her since childhood, exacerbated by her biological father’s negative attitude towards her. Despite years of trying to foster a sibling relationship, her stepsister has consistently expressed disinterest and disdain.

Recently, during a therapy session, when asked about her feelings, the girl expressed reluctance towards continuing family therapy. She openly admitted feeling that trying to force a loving relationship where none exists seems futile, especially given her stepsister’s clear and repeated declarations of indifference. This confession understandably came as a shock to her parents, who had hoped therapy would mend their family dynamics.

Her parents reacted strongly, expressing disappointment and urging her to put in effort because they believe change requires trying. The therapist intervened by speaking privately with the parents, though the outcome of that conversation is unclear to the girl.

Reflecting on her actions, the girl feels conflicted about causing distress to her parents but believes honesty about her feelings was necessary. She seeks validation for her decision to express her reluctance towards family therapy under the circumstances.

In conclusion, while the girl’s disclosure may have been jarring for her parents, her honesty about her feelings regarding the efficacy of family therapy does not necessarily make her the asshole (AITA). Given the long history of strained relations and her stepsister’s persistent rejection, her reservations about continuing therapy are understandable. The therapist’s role in mediating and addressing these concerns will be crucial in guiding the family towards a resolution that respects everyone’s emotional well-being.

Read for more info Reddit