“AITA for telling my aunt that her the reason none of her nieces or nephews like her is because of all her comments after a funeral?”

Based on the events described, it seems that tensions reached a breaking point for OP (21F) and her cousins due to the behavior of their aunt, “E,” during their uncle’s funeral. Throughout the day, Aunt E made inappropriate and hurtful comments about the appearance and emotions of family members, including critiques about clothing choices, tears, and weight. These comments were insensitive and deeply upsetting, particularly given the somber occasion.

After enduring Aunt E’s remarks all day, OP confronted her aunt during a gathering at her parents’ house. In a moment of frustration, OP expressed her feelings bluntly, telling Aunt E that her behavior was causing her to be disliked by her nieces and nephews, and that even her own children barely tolerate her. This confrontation led to Aunt E becoming emotional and crying.

OP’s mother later criticized her for being disrespectful, especially considering the timing right after the funeral. While OP’s cousins supported her stance and felt that Aunt E’s behavior warranted a response, others outside the immediate family viewed OP’s outburst as inappropriate given the circumstances.

In assessing whether OP was in the wrong, it’s clear that Aunt E’s comments were hurtful and inappropriate, and OP and her cousins reached their breaking point after enduring them throughout the day. While the timing of the confrontation was sensitive, it was provoked by Aunt E’s ongoing behavior, which had already caused considerable distress.

Ultimately, whether OP is considered the asshole (TA) depends on individual perspectives on how to handle such situations. Some may view OP’s outburst as justified given the circumstances, while others may believe it could have been addressed more tactfully or at a different time. The incident underscores the importance of addressing hurtful behavior while also considering the emotional context of family gatherings and funerals.

Read for more info Reddit

Here were the top rated comments from readers: