Woman bans brother and SIL from her home; 'Not after the OFFENSIVE LEFTOVERS fiasco.' AITA?

In this situation, the host, represented as “OP,” faced a dilemma after a contentious family gathering where a misunderstanding led to accusations and insults from their brother’s wife, Lucy. The conflict began when OP, in charge of leftover plates, gave several containers of food to their brother, John, to take home. Later, Lucy accused OP of keeping food meant for them, leading to a heated argument where Lucy made hurtful comments about OP’s appearance and financial status.

Despite subsequent apologies from Lucy upon learning the truth—that John had mistakenly eaten all the food and then lied about OP withholding it—the damage was done. OP chose not to invite John and Lucy to their next family gathering, citing ongoing hurt and unwillingness to forgive Lucy’s hurtful remarks. This decision caused further rifts within the family, with some members urging OP to reconcile and include John and Lucy, while others sympathized with OP’s hurt feelings and supported their decision to exclude them.

The situation escalated when OP’s mother intervened, urging reconciliation and encouraging OP to invite John and Lucy despite their refusal. OP remained steadfast, asserting that John and Lucy would not be welcome in their home if they chose to attend uninvited. This stance further exacerbated tensions within the family, with feelings running high on both sides.

Ultimately, OP faced criticism and support in equal measure from their family, highlighting the complex dynamics and deep-seated emotions involved. The fallout from the initial misunderstanding and subsequent fallout continued to strain relationships, leaving the family divided over whether OP’s decision to exclude John and Lucy was justified or excessive.

Read for more info Reddit