'AITA for losing it and telling in-laws to stop calling me 'mama' and trying to erase my identity?'

In this scenario, Carmen, a mother of two young daughters, finds herself frustrated and belittled by her in-laws’ persistent use of the term “mama” to refer to her rather than her name. During a family gathering over Christmas, Carmen repeatedly asks her in-laws, particularly her sisters-in-law (SILs), to address her by her name instead of “mama,” emphasizing that she wants to be recognized as an individual beyond her role as a mother.

Despite her requests, Carmen feels unheard and increasingly marginalized throughout the holiday. The situation escalates when Carmen confronts her SILs about the issue, expressing her discomfort with the way they and others have been defining her solely through her motherhood. This confrontation leads to emotional responses from both Carmen and her SILs, with accusations and attempts to shame Carmen for expressing her frustrations.

Carmen’s mother-in-law (MIL) attempts to diffuse the tension by apologizing and acknowledging Carmen’s feelings, but this gesture doesn’t fully resolve the underlying issue. Carmen’s husband, while sympathetic to her feelings, suggests that she should apologize for the outburst, which Carmen sees as unfair given her repeated attempts to address the issue calmly in the past.

The stalemate within the family reflects deeper tensions regarding identity, respect, and the roles women are expected to fulfill within familial dynamics. Carmen’s insistence on being addressed by her name underscores her desire to be seen and respected as more than just a mother. The conflict highlights broader societal expectations placed on women in relation to motherhood and individual identity.

Ultimately, the question of whether Carmen is the “asshole” (AITA) in this situation is complex. While her frustration is understandable given the repeated dismissal of her requests and the reduction of her identity to a maternal role, the manner in which she confronted her SILs could be seen as confrontational. However, her actions are rooted in a valid desire for recognition and respect, challenging the norms that often confine women to predefined roles within family dynamics.

Read for more info Reddit