"AITA For making a scene when my brothers girlfriend tried to protect her peace?"

In a family gathering that turned tense, a mother of an eleven-month-old baby found herself at odds with her brother’s girlfriend over breastfeeding. The baby, unusually large for his age, required frequent feeding sessions which became a point of discomfort for the girlfriend. Despite efforts to explain the baby’s needs, tensions boiled over when the girlfriend demanded accommodation away from the baby, citing discomfort and the belief that the child should be on solid foods.

The situation escalated when the mother, feeling unfairly judged and criticized, confronted the girlfriend for her lack of understanding about parenting and her insensitivity to the baby’s needs. Emotions ran high as arguments ensued, eventually leading to the girlfriend declaring her need to “protect her peace” and leaving the gathering.

Family reactions were mixed: while the father supported the mother’s stance, he suggested a more mature approach might have diffused the conflict. The mother’s own mother remained neutral but attempted to reconcile the situation by financially assisting the girlfriend’s stay elsewhere. The brother, however, sided with his girlfriend, accusing the mother of being immature and exacerbating the situation unnecessarily.

In reflection, opinions varied on whether the mother’s reaction was justified or excessive. Some sympathized with her frustration at being judged unfairly as a parent, while others felt she could have handled the disagreement with more composure. The incident left lingering tensions within the family, with unresolved feelings on both sides regarding the appropriateness of breastfeeding in public and the responsibilities of accommodating differing comfort levels in family gatherings.

Read for more info Reddit